PDF | Tradução de Bruno Ribeiro. Original: DESCOLA, Philippe. ‘Beyond Nature and Culture’, Proceedings of the British Academy, volume , pp. Philippe Descola’s Beyond Nature & Culture is not a modest book. Having first appeared French in , it systematizes some of the ideas. In this first part, I will present Philippe Descola and the big lines of the his In Beyond nature and culture, Descola shows that the opposition.
|Published (Last):||12 April 2008|
|PDF File Size:||10.58 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||15.20 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The danger natufe is not some little mental fisticuffs within an academic realm of discourse. The causal arrow, in my experience, tends to run mostly from resource bases, through the system of uses to which resources are put and distributed the economyand onward through customs and ideas about correct behaviour, all of which tend to attract like iron filings the actions, institutions and ideology that the cilture most closely to the path of that arrow.
Beyond Nature and Culture, Descola, Lloyd, Sahlins
This time, however, the contested notion of structure is put to use to deeply modify the limits of anthropology itself, since it is the very notion of nature descloa is being shifted from an indisputable resource to a highly local and historical topic of inquiry. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Certainly, in the minor ecological niche that interests me, which is ethnographic attention to the life sciences and the theory widely cited in that literatureit has been fairly settled, for some time now, that no meaningful ethnographic endeavor can ignore the strange traffic between, for example, bodies, laws, animals, affinities, laboratories, families, and so on Strathern, ; Haraway, ; Franklin, ; Fortun, The spears of twilight: This dualistic view has produced two dominant perspectives on human-nature relations in the history of the anthropological discipline:.
Still others are panicked by A consensus seems to be emerging among people in many fields from ecology to philosophy that dominance of anthropocentrism in Western culture is approaching an end, but remarkably few people have seriously tried to envision what this change would entail. That such ddscola lead to the eventual privatization of the land itself, and eventually to severe socio-economic stratification, was hardly foreseen or achieved by some deliberate plan.
Return to Book Page. This thought is found in many esoteric systems like divination, annd, Chinese medicine. Philippe Descola has become one of the most important anthropologists working today, and Beyond Nature and Culture has been a major influence drscola European intellectual life since its French publication in Still others are panicked by the prospect and describe it entirely in terms of negatives, for example a decline in human rights.
Here, finally, it is brought to English-language readers.
What about treating dolls like persons? Who is Philippe Descola? This is important, because many will come to Descola from an interest in a more contemporary and a more modest project — one that provincializes the basic figure of human subjectivity and intentionality, legislated at least in part by an historical division of nature and culture.
Precisely the opposite, in fact — his argument with naturalism is that it reduces and totalizes inefficiently; that it leaves too many strange scraps of human experience worryingly unaccounted for more than once, Descola gives us the study of chemistry as a model for his ambition .
Introduction session part 2: In contrast, animism give to non-human an interiority similar to human. I do not lament the anthropology of the s and s. The spears of twilightis a more a personal account of his experiences living with the Achuar accessible to a large public. According to him, anthropocentrism, found only in the modern Occident, is only one of four basic ontologies, with which people have tried to understand the world.
In fact we do not get, at any stage in this text, an account of who are the anthropologists so committed to the division of nature and culture.
Julie Rodrigue rated it really liked it Mar 12, Be the first naturs ask a question about Beyond Nature and Culture.
Beyond Nature and Culture by Philippe Descola
At its heart is a question central to both anthropology and philosophy: For example, ethnosciences interpret the environment in the light of classification vocabulary that organizes the world and orders plants, animals, etc.
Culture—as a collective human making, of art, language, and so forth—is often seen as essentially different from nature, which is portrayed as a collective of the nonhuman world, of plants, animals, geology, and natural forces. It would be rather a shame, I think, if we were to forget those reasons, in our scramble for the Big-Time. Rather, it was the slow modification of social conventions that left us with the vexing issue of the landless and the poverty stricken.
Journal of Ethnographic Theory
For more information, or to order this book, please visit https: Unless we clearly understand that planetary system in mind our analysis of humanity is futile.
Descola shows this essential difference to be, however, not only a specifically Descolaa notion, but also a very recent one.
Hannah Bunkin rated it it was amazing Jul 04, Ashveen rated it it was amazing Dec 18, In the final sections, Descola details six modes of relation that mediate these four primary modes of identification — exchange, predation and gift, on the one hand; production, protection and transmission, on the other It is on this great division between humanity and the world of nature that relay the academic division between natural sciences and humanities with: The four ontologies are 1 animism where there is an assumption that many human and non-human beings have similar interiorities to one another, but are made up of very different stuff ; 2 ; naturalism where all beings are radically separated by their internal lives, albeit made of basically the same substance ; 3 totemism in which there is continuity between both interiority behond physicality, across a very wide array of beings ; 4 analogism a sort of radical system of difference, in which each being has a uniquely constituted interior and physical existence Skip to content The objective of this seminar is to study the relations between natures and societies in Southeast Asia in the light of the work of the French anthropologist Philippe Descola.
Subjects of the World Paul Sheldon Davies. Marc Chataigner rated it it was amazing Oct 10, They think that wild animals and plants have a soul, act beond persons and share social values.